Why Choose Our Pizza?

We are pizza innovators! We also believe our brand should always come first, and since we do not have a brand to compete against, we are deeply dedicated to setting the bar high. We always hold ourselves to the highest standards when it comes to safety and quality.

Reviews

Click here to prove you are human.

Olga Bonvissuto November 22, 2025
"We were meaning to go there for a while, but for one reason or another never did it untill today's and we were not disappointed, the food was great, and the service amusing, friendly, outgoing and very adnowledge, we have a great time and good food. Definitely going back. We love it."
Leo Nardo November 9, 2025
"Had an awesome meal at Greek’s Pizzeria! The pizza was amazing — super fresh, cheesy, and full of flavor. The prices were fair and the portions were generous, perfect for a nice casual meal. The staff was really friendly and made the experience even better. Definitely one of my new favorite pizza spots in Indiana — I’ll be back for sure! 🍕"
Angela Adams October 28, 2025
"First time there and it reminded me of a pizza place from my childhood. TVs had old cartoons on and loved the pinball machine."
William Turner October 26, 2025
"Slower than other Greek's Pizzerias, but food was very good and staff was friendly"
John Casbon October 12, 2025
"One of my favorite pizza joints in Valparasio, we have been coming here for many years I took my kids here and now have a granddaughter working there. Great food and very friendly service 👍 👍"
Jason Bales September 16, 2025
"If I could give more than 5 stars, I would! A few weeks ago, my wife and I asked the staff to assist us in surprising our family with some news (pregnancy announcement!) and they went above and beyond to be helpful. We wanted to personally thank all staff who was present that day: Riley, Ella, Goldie, Autumn, Syd, Ben, and Gunnar. (I hope I spelled all of those correctly!) Riley, you were such a huge help and we are so grateful for you helping us to make that such a fun, impactful moment for us. Thank you all so much again, and thank you to the Karamesines family for the years of great food, service, and memories. Cheers!"