Why Choose Our Pizza?
We are pizza innovators! We also believe our brand should always come first, and since we do not have a brand to compete against, we are deeply dedicated to setting the bar high. We always hold ourselves to the highest standards when it comes to safety and quality.Reviews
December 13, 2025
"My family discovered Menny’s pizzeria about a year ago and after trying a handful of different spots, we’ve been coming here almost every week since.
I generally don’t write reviews, but it’s hard to find great customer service these days. You can tell a lot about a place based on how they treat customers when things go wrong.
Last Friday, I ordered 2 pizzas and one of the pizza orders was incorrectly taken. Also, instead noting the order for delivery, they had marked it for pickup. Needless to say, with hungry kids, it was not a great situation. I called after an hour and they quickly rushed the order to me.
In addition, they acknowledged they had incorrectly taken the order for one of the pizzas and credited the entire order.
The owner personally called and we came back today and both pizzas (and knots) were cooked to perfection.
Would highly recommend ordering, and dining in and we will continue to come here.
Our favorites include:
(1) What’s in the box with garlic, dipped in their garlic sauce
(2) Cheese pizza, cooked what’s in the box style if you like a nice doughy pizza. At least that’s what my two kids can’t get enough of.
(3) can’t go wrong with the cinnamon sugar knots"
November 22, 2025
"We were meaning to go there for a while, but for one reason or another never did it untill today's and we were not disappointed, the food was great, and the service amusing, friendly, outgoing and very adnowledge, we have a great time and good food. Definitely going back. We love it."
November 9, 2025
"Had an awesome meal at Greek’s Pizzeria! The pizza was amazing — super fresh, cheesy, and full of flavor. The prices were fair and the portions were generous, perfect for a nice casual meal. The staff was really friendly and made the experience even better. Definitely one of my new favorite pizza spots in Indiana — I’ll be back for sure! 🍕"
October 28, 2025
"First time there and it reminded me of a pizza place from my childhood. TVs had old cartoons on and loved the pinball machine."
October 26, 2025
"Slower than other Greek's Pizzerias, but food was very good and staff was friendly"
October 12, 2025
"One of my favorite pizza joints in Valparasio, we have been coming here for many years I took my kids here and now have a granddaughter working there. Great food and very friendly service
👍 👍"